Why Solar Thermal Is Quietly Losing To Solar PV

Kavita Shyam
11 Min Read

Solar thermal feels like a genuinely smart option for many people, and once you understand how it works, it starts to make real sense. Unlike regular solar panels that produce electricity, solar thermal systems grab the sun’s heat directly and use it to warm water in your home.

For most UK households, this means you get a steady supply of hot water powered by free solar energy, especially through the summer months, which seriously helps in reducing reliance on gas and electric immersion heating.

The role of solar thermal in building truly low-carbon homes has shifted, because installations are now in steep decline while solar PV and heat pumps dominate most home-energy strategies built around decarbonisation.

Using renewable energy to push hot water through to your taps and showers, solar thermal works by circulating glycol fluid through the collectors, which absorbs solar energy and delivers it straight into your hot water.

How Solar Thermal Works

Solar thermal, or solar water heating as many engineers call it, is actually a beautifully simple technology once you break it down.

Roof-mounted collectors sit on your roof and pull in sunlight, and depending on the design, you either get flat-plate collectors, which are rectangular panels fixed flush against the roof or evacuated-tube collectors, which use cylindrical tubes and tend to be far more efficient in cooler and cloudier conditions.

From there, the system handles heat transfer by warming either water or a heat-transfer fluid and sending it down into the hot-water cylinder, where it does its job quietly and consistently.

A small pump keeps everything moving through the loop, while a smart controller makes sure the system only operates when it genuinely makes sense to do so, protecting efficiency at every stage. When the sun can’t do enough, your backup heating kicks in your existing boiler or immersion heater steps up to make sure you never run short.

In real-world use, these systems mostly pre-heat water rather than fully heat it, but solid UK data shows they can cover between 40–60% of your annual hot-water demand, with summer months obviously outperforming winter ones.

The system also uses glycol with antifreeze properties flowing through the collectors into a copper coil, warming your hot water tank through a carefully managed cycle, and a built-in control system prevents freezing liquid from actually cooling the tank back down on colder days.

Solar thermal technology harnessing solar energy to generate heat.

Complementing Your Heating System

Solar thermal panels work best when they slot neatly alongside your existing boiler rather than trying to replace it entirely.

If you already run a system boiler or a regular boiler paired with a solar-compatible hot water cylinder, you are in the ideal position to get the best results from day one.

Solar cylinders are cleverly built with two heating coils, one connects to your boiler central heating system, and the other hooks directly into the Greenskies solar thermal system, keeping both energy sources working efficiently together.

Some combi boilers can also integrate with solar thermal, but this depends on the specific model and setup, so always get advice from a qualified local installer before making any assumptions.

The system also connects well with air source heat pumps and ground source heat pumps, which makes it a flexible choice for homes already moving toward low-carbon heating. Whatever your current setup looks like, your boiler or heat pump always stands ready to cover any shortfall in your hot water requirements, so you never end up without hot water even on the darkest days of the year.

Installations in Decline: What the Data Shows

The numbers around solar thermal installation rates in UK homes tell a very clear story, and it’s one that every potential buyer should understand before committing.

MCS-certified figures for domestic solar thermal installations show a dramatic collapse: 571 in 2022, dropping to 300 in 2023, then 173 in 2024, falling further to just 65 in 2025, and reaching a near-total collapse with only 4 recorded in 2026.

To put that in perspective, only around 0.2% of UK homes currently have solar thermal installed, while approximately 5% now have solar PV, with adoption continuing to climb year on year.

The direction of travel is unmistakable: households, installers, and policy have all moved decisively toward heat pumps and solar PV as the twin engines of home decarbonisation.

Costs, Savings, and Carbon Impact

Looking at real MCS domestic installation data, the cost picture for solar thermal has stayed stubbornly high and frustratingly variable over recent years.

The table of average domestic solar thermal installation costs across the UK tells the story clearly: in 2022, the average cost per kW sat at £2,283 with a total of £5,694, rising in 2023 to £3,217 per kW and £5,526 overall.

Then £3,316 per kW and £5,877 in 2024, dipping slightly to £2,493 per kW and £5,419 in 2025 before climbing again to £3,465 per kW and £6,064 in 2026. The upfront cost has consistently sat between £5,000 and £6,000, even while the price of solar PV has dropped dramatically over the same period.

On the positive side, running costs are genuinely low; the pumps use tiny amounts of electricity, and maintenance is infrequent enough that it rarely becomes a burden.

Real-world field trials run by the Energy Saving Trust found that well-installed systems delivered around 39% of annual hot-water demand on average, with the best setups reaching 60%.

Translated into money, that means typical annual savings of £55–£110 for gas-heated water homes and £80–£210 for those running electric immersion systems, but these figures shift considerably depending on hot-water use, tariffs, and system design.

Long payback periods are the uncomfortable reality for most gas-heated homes, which goes a long way toward explaining the collapse in demand.

Solar Thermal vs Alternatives

When you put a heat pump head-to-head with solar thermal, the differences become very obvious very quickly.

A heat pump handles both space heating and water heating in one system, delivering significant carbon savings and major cuts to overall energy reductions across the whole home, though it may need radiator upgrades or improved insulation upgrades to perform at its best.

It focuses purely on hot water, offering genuinely free solar heat and impressively low running cost, but it stays firmly roof and usage dependent, which limits how many homes can actually benefit.

Solar PV sits in its own lane entirely, focused on electricity generation rather than heat, and its big strengths are that it is flexible, scalable, and fully exportable, qualities that solar thermal simply cannot match.

When these technologies work inside properly designed integrated systems, PV and heat pumps consistently unlock broader and more genuinely flexible benefits for the vast majority of homeowners. Solar thermal still has a place in the right context, but it rarely competes on equal terms with either alternative when considered as a standalone choice.

Limitations to Be Aware Of

The most fundamental limitation is that it only offsets your hot-water energy use  it makes absolutely no dent in your household electricity demand, which is where most modern energy costs are heading.

Upfront costs remain painfully high relative to the savings achievable in gas-heated homes, and that mismatch is one of the hardest things to talk around when advising homeowners.

Government grants and incentives have largely moved on, with funding now pointed firmly at heat pumps and solar PV rather than solar thermal.

The honest reality is that payback periods often stretch close to or beyond the system lifetime itself, especially when you compare the returns against a PV system that actively chips away at electricity bills and grid imports simultaneously.

Meanwhile, solar PV gives you electricity you can export for payment, run through heat pumps, power your appliances, and charge your EVs, a level of versatility that solar thermal simply cannot replicate.

Our Recommendation

After honestly weighing up everything that solar PV and solar thermal each bring to the table, the case for solar PV wins convincingly on flexibility and cost-efficiency in almost every realistic household scenario.

Generating electricity for your home is simply more powerful and more future-proof than generating hot water alone, because electricity can do both jobs while hot water can only do one.

That’s exactly why, as installers and advisers, we choose to supply and install only solar PV systems for the homes we work with.

Leave a comment